Obams…
June 4, 2009, 12:12 AM
Filed under: America, Barack Obama, Frustrations, Israel, Politics

Nearly six full months later…I’m back? Lets jump straight in.

Most of you know – certainly anyone who has read these pages does – that I have supported President Obama from day one. I enjoyed his address at the DNC in 2004, forgot about him during his following months as Junior Senator from Illinois, and quickly picked up pace by the time significant Presidential aspirations seemed eminent.

Watching the two night NBC Brian Williams special with my mom this evening, she remarked on how extraordinary she thinks Obama is – and I agreed. His charisma and shining intellect finally provide a President fit for the job – and 63% of American agree! Hooray approval ratings! Americans; we; I, love his ability to articulate his opinion (eight years was a long time), his open-mindedness, and his eagerness to reconnect with the rest of the world. Read: the Arab world.

Yeah. I said it. Ready for the kicker?

I think not sugar-coating everything the United States has to do with Israel isn’t the worst foreign policy move, either, though that one took me a long time to say. Don’t get too excited – that’s as far as I’ll go. Phew.

For quite some time I have held the belief that being a supportive critic of something (something = Israel) is both more productive and indicative of a working relationship than supporting that something without discretion. Read simply: blind support of Israel, though an 8-year Bush policy, is a shitty policy. Note: the 8 year Bush policy consisted of 6 years of not getting involved at all, and 2 years of false promises and failed conferences.

For several months I have been quiet about my thoughts regarding Israel, perhaps, simply, because it is incredibly difficult to criticise her, at times, without being labeled an anti-Zionist, which I am not, or instilling the wrath of right-wingers (of both the Israeli and American political spectrum, though primarily the former). Difficulties also lie in figuring out what I think – something I still need to work on. Either way, let it be made clear that I support and adore Israel, for many of the things she offers her citizens and the world. She is unique in the technology produced within her borders, but above all in the role she serves as the home of so many different people: a homeland both literal and metaphorical for Jews, Muslims and Christians alike.

Israel’s neighborhood and her interactions with those neighbors, though, has up until this point, and likely far past it, been the focus of any significant debate. Indeed, as President Obama prepares to address the Arab world from Cairo in a mere six hours (6:45 am EST) his main objective will be to begin a new page and attitude in US-Arab relations. Of course, I don’t know what the guidelines of this new page will be – that is yet to be seen, and should not be taken at face value, but rather as those guidelines are carried out. Regardless, I am glad that we are taking a step forward in our relations with the Arab world, as the previous administration seemed only to dig a hole that Obama is only beginning to climb out of. So many of my friends and the publications I read (sporadically) are filled with inadvertant, and sometimes blatant racism towards Arabs. Though terrorism and awful attacks both verbal, mental, and physical towards Jews and the Jewish state drive me up the wall, Israel and her supporters need to take the moral high-road and embrace the Jewish values of loving our neighbors and pursuing peace.

And still, I worry.

My worries, it seems, stem from the consequence that this new set of Obama policies will have on Israel – particularly her safety. It is still not clear to me, for example, how far Obama will actually let Iran’s “peaceful” nuclear aspirations go. I am confident in Tzahal’s ability to maintain a secure Jewish state, but the US has and always will be (G!d willing) Israel’s biggest ally. Without us, the list is short…

As for Obama’s urge (request? demand?) that Israel remove its citizens from, and demolish, settlements (yes, including natural growth), I have mixed emotions. I am surely not as educated as I need to be on the topic to fully weigh in on it, but I find it difficult both to make Israeli settlers leave land that, supposedly, they bought, and leave them displaced. In addition, recalling recent history of demolishing Israeli homes (Summer 2006), returning that land to Palestinians, only to watch terrorists shoot rockets from said land in return does not leave me feeling warm and fuzzy. Where is the incentive for Israel in that move? Or removing itself to 1967 borders, for that matter? This issue is a blog post in itself, so I’ll save it.

Excuse this jumble of a post. My thoughts on all of these issues and more remain cloudy on a good day – clearly I have significant thinking to do. In the meantime, I am not particularly optimistic for any major breakthroughs soon – with Bibi’s stubbornness and Avigdor Leibermans (blatant) racism, not to mention infighting and significant sectarian issues amongst the Palestinians, who remain without a leader. Both sides have significant ways to go. The only upside being I have a lot more time to write about it…

We’ll see what Obama says. Will you be listening?


1 Comment so far
Leave a comment

Mark,

I hate to break it to you, but Obama is nothing but a fake. I know, it’s so difficult to hear it but it is true. The charisma and shining intellect you so admire in Obama is nothing but an act he puts on to make people like him. His need to surround himself with celebrities is part of the whole act. He uses them to show how relatable he is and that he is hip and young. It’s all an act. He sat on a throne of false hope for the people in America during elections. Now that he is president he has turned his back on many of the communities that supported his campaign. To start, the gay community. Obama has betrayed their confidence in him to make a “change”, as he likes to call it, and support the institution of same sex marriage. He has fallen silent on the subject and left his gay supporters standing alone and feeling the wrath of an unchanging society. The Jewish community has been left out in the cold as well. In a Jewish newspaper in Chicago a rabbi was quoted as saying that Obama is not the first black president, he is the first Jewish president. During elections Obama cozied up to the Jewish community in hopes for their very influential support. Now, he is sympathizing with Palestinian terrorists set on destroying Israel. There is a difference between forging connections between enemies and sympathizing with a terrorist government and forcing an ally into a situation that is unsafe for its people. Obama is the end for Israel.

It sounds harsh, but it is so clear. Obama has no right to push the Israeli government into giving away land, especially land that is strategically unsafe for Israel to give away including the Golan and East Jerusalem. Israel is an ally of America and we should not force our friends into situations that will harm its people. If the PA or Hamas are given control over East Jerusalem or the Golan, Israel will be in the same situation it has with Gaza and neighboring Israeli cities like Sderot. Violence and rockets will be ceaseless in the areas surrounding. For the sake of its own people, Israel cannot afford to give up these lands. Land for peace doesn’t work and we’ve seen this many times in the past. The PA is unwilling to recognize the state of Israel and will not stop anti-Israel and anti-Jewish propaganda in its territories. If Israel relinquishes the land they are demanding it will only be a breeding ground for Israel haters. Why is it that the PA can have its demands met with the support of Obama, but Israel cannot? Obama only tells Israel what it has to do. When Israel doesn’t want to do it then it is being stubborn and unwillingly to embark on the path for peace. When the PA outwardly says it will never recognize Israel as a Jewish State, which was one of Israel’s conditions, no one says that they are in the wrong. Obama cannot expect Israel to forget their conditions for peace if the PA won’t do the same. Obama is only looking to have Israel lose everything in order to achieve peace. He is sympathizing with terrorists and that is a big problem.

Furthermore, if Obama finds it so important for Israel to start giving back “occupied” territories, then America should step up itself and not be a hypocrite. All American territory taken from the Native Americans should be returned. All American territory taken from any other country or people should be returned to their hands. It’s only fair right? If America finds Israel’s acquiring of land to be occupation, then America should end its own occupation as well.

That’s how I feel about it. If Obama is willing to risk the lives of Israelis in order to achieve a Palestinian state then there is definitely something wrong with that. He is willing to have Israeli blood on his hands in order to create his own legacy. Not only that, but Americans live and travel to Jerusalem and the Golan and with a Palestinian state sitting within reach he is risking having the blood of Americans on his hands too. He may not be for the spilling of innocent blood in Iraq, but he sure doesn’t mind having it spilt in Israel. That is more than troubling.

P.S. I love you Mark.

Comment by BC




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>